What Happens When Addicts Are Treated With Dignity by the Court System?

By Edie Weinstein, LSW Follow Edie at Twitter @Edie Weinstein1

Drug court. These two words are fraught with trepidation for many whose addictions have brought them into contact with the legal system. It can be a place where people who may already feel demoralized by the drugs that have ravaged their bodies and minds face a potentially demeaning judge who sees them as just another number on the docket. It may also be a room from which they can launch a new life.

It is meant to be far more than punitive, offering addicts an incentive to enter and complete treatment. Drug court falls under the category of therapeutic jurisprudence that is defined by Black’s Law Dictionary as “the study of how legal systems affect the emotions, behaviors and the mental health of people.”

The term was coined by Professor David Wexler, of the University of Arizona, Rogers College of Law and University of Puerto Rico School of Law, in a paper delivered to the National Institute of Mental Health in 1987.

The National Association of Drug Court Professionals indicates that the “average recidivism rate for drug court graduates is between 4 percent and 29 percent as compared with 48 percent for non-participants.”

It outlines the program:

Eligible drug-addicted persons may be sent to drug court in lieu of traditional justice system case processing. Drug courts keep individuals in treatment long enough for it to work, while supervising them closely. For a minimum term of one year, participants are:

  • Provided with intensive treatment and other services they require to get and stay clean and sober
  • Held accountable by the drug court judge for meeting their obligations to the court, society, themselves and their families
  • Regularly and randomly tested for drug use
  • Required to appear in court frequently so that the judge may review their progress and reward them for doing well or sanction them when they do not live up to their obligation

Compassionate Judges Make a Difference 

Newark, New Jersey, Municipal Court Judge Victoria Pratt sees far more than criminals standing before her each day. She observes people whose poor decisions have landed them in her courtroom. She envisions redemption and renewal for them and engages with them as a partner in creating a brighter future. Pratt is caring, but also “no nonsense” in her approach to justice. She interacts with them in ways that demonstrate interest in their lives, as she encourages responsible parenting, re-establishing relationships and claiming, perhaps for the first time, the personal dignity that is foundational in sustaining sobriety.

“This court is going to treat you with dignity and respect, and we expect you to treat us the same way,” she tells defendants. “If you show up late or don’t show up at all, you will serve a jail sentence.”

Most show up and follow through on her mandates that address the particular crimes they have committed.

Pratt often gives a writing assignment, asking them to pen an essay that describes where they see themselves in five years, highlighting the scenarios as if they are playing out in the present moment. She then has them read the essay before her — in part because deciphering another’s handwriting can be a challenge. She also finds that by expressing their story aloud, the person gains a sense of empowerment. The benefits of such an exercise are multifold:

  • It aids the writer in envisioning a life beyond crime and addiction, since often that seems inconceivable.
  • It solidifies the images in their mind by putting them in writing, thus making them attainable.
  • It engages inspired action to see the ideas come to fruition.
  • It holds the person accountable for follow through, since his or her declaration is being witnessed by a room full of people.
  • It offers support, so the person may feel that they need not do this alone.
  • It gives them structure and focus.
  • It helps them to regain activities that they may have left behind prior to addiction.
  • It allows for imagining the steps that it might take to traverse the path from where they are to where they want to be.
  • It endeavors to break the steps down into manageable activities.
  • It provides a milestone to celebrate when they achieve it. 

Throwing the Book at Courtroom Defendants

In Baltimore area courts, judges are taking the opportunity to hand out reading assignments while they simultaneously hand down verdicts. Judge Lewis A. Becker has those who present themselves before him with charges related to alcohol read Under the Influence as a means of highlighting the dangers of driving impaired. The next step is writing a 1,500 word essay describing the insights they gleaned from it. Those with heroin addiction are instructed by Judge James N. Vaughan to read The Corner, and to those who have stolen, the classic Les Miserables.

While it may not be the final word, by treating with compassion and dignity those whose addictions have led them to stand before the black-robed authority figure, the chances of a return visit are diminished and the opportunities to recover are enhanced.

Getting Out From Under: What to Do If Your Partner Continues to Drink or Use

Whether your partner has gone through rehab or continues to make promises that are never kept about cutting down his or her use of alcohol or drugs, you know the sinking feeling when you come face to face with the reality that the situation isn’t going to change. Now you’re faced with a tough decision. While you’re contemplating getting out from under, it’s important to know what to do if your partner continues to drink or use. Continue reading

How to Handle (or Survive) Your First 12-Step Meeting

12 step meeting - group of people sitting in a circle

After you’ve made the often very difficult decision to go into rehab and get professional help to overcome your addiction, it’s not the end of the healing path but merely the beginning. Along with detoxifying your body from addictive substances, learning about the disease of addiction, becoming familiar with and practicing coping skills and techniques, and learning how to prevent, deal with and come back from potential relapse, there’s the whole vital element of ongoing support to navigate. While you’ve probably been introduced to 12-step meetings, once you’re back home again you’ll need to figure out how to handle (or survive) your first (post-rehab) 12-step meeting. Continue reading

Alternatives to 12-Step Addiction Recovery

girl smiling sitting on a swing

While many drug and alcohol rehab centers have a focus on the 12 steps in the overall healing process, there are alternative programs that you should be aware of. This is perhaps of particular importance to those who want to overcome addiction to toxic substances but don’t like the idea of or don’t feel comfortable with any program that emphasizes a higher power.

It should be noted, though, that even Alcoholics Anonymous, the original 12-step group, while it does mention higher power, also says, or “God as we know Him.” You don’t have to be religious or belong to a specific church, congregation, temple, mosque or synagogue to benefit from any of the 12-step programs. Still, if you’re interested in what else is out there, here are some of the alternatives to 12-step recovery. Continue reading

Getting Out From Under: What to Do If Your Partner Continues to Drink or Use

Eight Identified Categories of Drinkers


Whether your partner has gone through rehab or continues to make promises that are never kept about cutting down his or her use of alcohol or drugs, you know the sinking feeling when you come face to face with the reality that the situation isn’t going to change. Now you’re faced with a tough decision. While you’re contemplating getting out from under, it’s important to know what to do if your partner continues to drink or use. Continue reading

Why First Responders Need Trauma Treatment and Shouldn’t Be Ashamed of Getting It

two firemen in front of a fire

Each day, first responders are faced with many forms of extreme stress including life-and-death decisions, human suffering, separation from family and intense risk-taking. While those in this profession have chosen this lifestyle and wouldn’t have it any other way, it’s a high-stress career that can lead to both physical and emotional injuries.

Emergency medical technicians, fire fighters, paramedics, police officers and other first responders are required to remain in control of their emotions at all times. There is no time for on-the-job meltdowns, and many in these helping professions force themselves to be calm and in control even when experiencing a great deal of emotional turbulence. Continue reading

Zen and Washing Dishes: How to Be Mindful in Everyday Tasks

mindfulness meditation

With all the emphasis on the benefits of mindfulness meditation, you might think that the practice involves drastic changes in your everyday routine. This might not sound all that appealing, considering all the must-do items you have already on your list, especially since you’re now in recovery. There is, however, a way to incorporate mindfulness into almost everything you do. Here’s a look at how to be mindful in everyday tasks. Continue reading

How Utah Is Addressing the State’s Opioid Epidemic

Drug rehab centers in Utah

The use of prescription and illicit opioids led to over 33,000 deaths in the U.S. in 2015, a figure that has quadrupled since 1999, according to the CDC. The problem stems from prescription painkillers like OxyContin and fentanyl, which share close similarities with drugs like heroin and morphine, but are widely prescribed to people in moderate or severe pain. While the medications can help people in pain live normal lives, they carry a big risk of addiction, and drug rehab centers in Utah and around the country have noted a big increase in patients with opioid addictions. But what can we do about it? How can states resolve the growing problem? Continue reading

How to Tell If You’re Addicted to Your ADHD Medication

ADHD Banner with Medication

Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a serious condition that affects adults as well as children and teens. Stimulant medications are effective in treating this condition, but concerns about the potential for abuse of these medications, or even addiction to them, (Focalin addiction, Adderall addiction, and Ritalin addiction) are valid. Let’s take a closer look at how to discern if you are developing an addiction to the medications prescribed for your ADHD.

Continue reading

911 for First Responders: Resolving Cumulative Trauma by Supporting Each Other

By Mike Pool, Retired Law Enforcement and Peer Coordinator of After Action: Building Resilience Workshop.

First responders are not allowed to show or share our emotions. We shove our reactions as far down as they’ll go so we can cope with the day-to-day corrosive events of our jobs. Most of us come to see that this kind of work found us, and not the other way around, so we plunge head first into trying to do our best. Many of us don’t realize how much our family history may have led us on this path, or the underlying reasons we need to protect and save people. We just get it done. Continue reading